|
| 2014 | Johns Hopkins | (Taylor Kitayama, Margaret Storm, Kylie Ternes, Anastasia Bogdanovski) | 3:42.90 |
| 2013 | Kenyon | (Celia Oberholzer, Katie Kaestner, Hannah Saiz, Haley Townsend) | 3:40.13 |
| 2012 | Williams | (Sarah Thompson, Caroline Wilson, Logan Todhunter, Carolyn Geller) | 3:42.21 |
| 2011 | Emory | (Sadie Nenning, April Whitley, Leslie Hackler, Clair Pavlak) | 3:42.82 |
| 2010 | Denison | (Olivia Zaleski, Gail Blachly, Kate Rich, Alyssa Swanson) | 3:43.94 |
| 2009 | Denison | (Olivia Zaleski, Ksenia Golovkina, Kate Rich, Kristen Hohl) | 3:43.42 |
| 2008 | Amherst | (Brittany Sasser, Ellen Fitzgerald, Kendra Stern, Meaghan Stern) | 3:46.87 |
| 2007 | Kenyon | (Carolyn Barer, Jessica Connors, Tina Ertel, Elizabeth Carlton) | 3:48.39 |
| 2006 | Williams | (Meghan Faughnan, Lindsay Payne, Chrissy Haley, Lauren Edmondson) | 3:49.81 |
| 2005 | Williams | (Jessica Yankura, Lindsay Payne, Mary Stranghoener, Kaite O'Brien) | 3:48.75 |
| 2004 | Kenyon | (Beth Galloway, Meilyn Chan, Jessica Connors, Marissa Stearns) | 3:50.29 |
| 2003 | Kenyon | (Beth Galloway, Betsy Garratt, Meilyn Chan, Agnese Ozolina) | 3:57.53 |
| 2002 | Denison | (Leah Favret, Alyssa Heidinger, Mollie Parrish, Kate Flikkema) | 3:48.06 |
| 2001 | Denison | (Leah Favret, Alyssa Heidinger, Mollie Parrish, Kate Flikkema) | 3:46.11 |
| 2000 | Kenyon | (Erica Carroll, Betsy Garratt, Madeleine Courtney-Brooks, Sarah Leone) | 3:51.95 |
| 1999 | Denison | (Erin Clark, Lauren Smith, Allison Edsall, Kelly Lotts) | 3:50.76 |
| 1998 | Denison | (Allison Edsall, Lauren Smith, Anna Tuttle, Kelly Lotts) | 3:51.84 |
| 1997 | Kenyon | (Kathryn Petrock, Rachel Schiming, Anna Drejer, Marisha Stawiski) | 3:50.24 |
| 1996 | Kenyon | (Kathryn Petrock, Rachel Schiming, Anna Drejer, Shelly Baker) | 3:56.77 |
| 1995 | Williams | (Robin Truelove, Deborah Palmer, Marla Robertson, Gretchen Von Oesen) | 3:56.79 |
| 1994 | Hope | (Susan Looman, Megan Hunter, Dawn Hoving, Sarah DeWitt) | 3:53.23 |
| 1993 | Kenyon | (Catherine Haight, Jennifer Carter, Shelly Baker, Carla Ainsworth) | 3:51.85 |
| 1992 | Kenyon | (Carolyn Peticolas, Jennifer Carter, Kristie Stacy, Carla Ainsworth) | 3:53.66 |
| 1991 | Kenyon | (Kami Mathews, Jennifer Carter, Kristie Stacy, Tasha Willis) | 3:54.65 |
| 1990 | Kenyon | (Kami Mathews, Jennifer Carter, Kristie Stacy, Traci Hockman) | 3:57.52 |
| 1989 | Kenyon | (Erin Finneran, Jeannine Gury, Kristie Stacy, Kami Mathews) | 3:56.88 |
| 1988 | Kenyon | (Erin Finneran, Jeannine Gury,Rebecca Little, Annette Laursen) | 3:55.24 |
| 1987 | Kenyon | (Erin Finneran, Jeannine Gury, Amy Heasley, Patricia Abt) | 3:52.97 |
| 1986 | Kenyon | (Christine Jacob, Deborah Neil, Barbara Misener, Teresa Zurick) | 3:58.80 |
| 1985 | Kenyon | (Bethann Welty, Deborah Neil, Barbara Misener, Patricia Abt) | 3:59.28 |
| 1984 | Williams | (Joan Horgan, Katherine Eckrich, Cecelia Ciepeila, Susan Knapp) | 4:03.37 |
| 1983 | Williams | (Kathryn Kirmayer, Katherine Eckrich, Elizabeth Jex, Katherine Hudner) | 4:04.89 |
| 1982 | Williams | (Cecelia Ciepeila, Katherine Eckrich, Catherine Hartley, Katherine Hudner) | 4:07.02 |
