| Year |
Name |
| 2025 |
Will Domineau, Sam Finnerty, Jared Hancock, Caleb Kirkpatrick, Dominic Simpson |
| 2024 |
Andy Canonico, Drake Lewis, Park Penrod, Dominic Simpson |
| 2023 |
Andy Canonico, Cole Garrison, Cole Kirol, Drake Lewis, Jaden Stewart |
| 2022 |
Jason Kessler, Mychael Leno, Isaiah Mann, Finn Murray, Ryan O'Leary |
| 2021 |
A.J. Allen, Mychael Leno |
| 2020 |
No captains due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2019 |
Sam Dickey, Chase Kirol, Thomas Merkle, Michael Picone |
| 2018 |
Thomas Merkle, Rob Meagher |
| 2017 |
Brandon Byrd, Ian Bell, Curt Williams |
| 2016 |
Brian Hunca, Cody Keenan |
| 2015Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â |
Blake Calcei, Jake Bates, Alexander McQuiston |
| 2014 |
Jake Bates, Alexander McQuiston, Garrison Anderson |
| 2013 |
David Brackett, Sam McQuiston, Reed Franklin |
| 2012 |
Dan Shannon, David Brackett, Luke Bissinger |
| 2011Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â |
Dan Shannon, Michael Papagni, Jeremy Oller, Alex Traugutt |
| 2010 |
Beau Calcei, Jeremy Oller, Mark Sullivan, Brandon Ventling |
| 2009 |
Mike Hermanson, Justin Morgan, Dan Runnals |
| 2008 |
Yancy Edwards, Andy Henry, Justin Morgan |
| 2007 |
Mike Chase, Carlin Shoemaker |
| 2006 |
David Cicetti, Alby Coombs, William Lippert, Carlin Shoemaker |
| 2005 |
Andrew Hammack, Casey McConnell |
| 2004 |
Derick Busenberg, Calvin Hatfield |
| 2003 |
Joe Craig, Casey McConnell |
| 2002 |
Dave Contrada, Joe Craig, Adam Partridge, Jeremiah Thompson |
| 2001 |
Tony Miga, Andy Mills |
| 2000 |
Mark Foran, Andrew Malone |
| 1999 |
Ian Nickey, Will Winnicki |
| 1998 |
Terry Parmalee, Tom Swain |
| 1997 |
Stan Hughes, Todd Kiziminski |
| 1996 |
Derrick Johnson |
| 1995 |
Aasem Khalil, Christian Ball, Brian Kiscoe, Mylin Johnson |
| 1994 |
Brett Brownscombe, Brad Hensley |
| 1993 |
Brad Hensley, Ted Brockman, Joe Gucanac |
| 1992 |
Joe St. Julian, John St. Julian |
| 1991 |
Herman Holt, Mike Menges, Sean McCabe |
| 1990 |
Ted Taggart, Duff Berschback, Chris Creighton |
| 1989 |
Stephen Baldwin, William Gerstler, Robert Nagucki |
| 1988 |
Eric Dahlquist, Alec Jerome, Pete Murphy |
| 1987 |
Jack Bresnicky, Brian Conkle, Marc Williams, John Rhoads |
| 1986 |
Dan Waldeck, Tim Rogers |
| 1985 |
Matt Lampe, Adam Davidson, Mike Dulske |
| 1984 |
David Morrison, William Stavole, Dan Pantic, Todd Stoner |
| 1983 |
James Balliett, Thomas Dazey, Doug Heuck |
| 1982 |
Mike Dillon, Graham Heasley, Zachary Space, Ross Miller |
| 1981 |
Jim Ginley, John MacKessy |
| 1980 |
Doug Beach, John Washko |
| 1979 |
Phil Dilts, Ron Anderson, Mike Svihra, Greg Niehaus |
| 1978 |
Roger Vaughan, Dave Nees |
| 1977 |
Robert Jennings, Warren Martin |
| 1976 |
Ken Nugent, John Polena |
| 1975 |
Marl Leonard, George Guzauskas, Bruce Broxterman, Dennis Hall |
| 1974 |
Pat Clements, Bruce Broxterman |
| 1973 |
Michael Gibbons, George Letts, Kent McDonald |
| 1972 |
Daniel Handel, James Musbach |
| 1971 |
- |
| 1970 |
- |
| 1969 |
- |
| 1968 |
- |
| 1967 |
- |
| 1966 |
William Brown, Gary Pendergraph |
| 1965 |
John Rutter, William Brown |
| 1964 |
Kenneth Klug, Paul Zuydhock |
| 1963 |
Michael Wood, Barry Lentz |
| 1962 |
George Schladen, Terry Owen |
| 1961 |
Nathan Withington |
| 1960 |
Hutchins Hodgson, Robert Weidenkopf |
| 1959 |
- |
| 1958 |
Joel Holmes, Charles Thompson |
| 1957 |
John Beese, Keith Brown |
| 1956 |
Clifford Smith, Richard Fesler |
| 1955 |
- |
| 1954 |
- |
| 1953 |
- |
| 1952 |
- |
| 1951 |
William Raney |
| 1950 |
Ross Haskell |
| 1949 |
Ross Haskell |
| 1948 |
- |
| 1947 |
Richard Fornoff |
| 1946 |
Arthur Vail, Carl Cooke |
| 1945 |
William M. Marshall |
| 1944 |
- |
| 1943 |
- |
| 1942 |
- |
| 1941 |
Gabriel Paolozzi |
| 1940 |
King Lees |
| 1939 |
Richard Olin |
| 1938 |
Raymond Ioanes |
| 1937 |
Arthur Boren, David Jasper |
| 1936 |
Carleton Taylor |
| 1935 |
Carleton Taylor |
| 1934 |
Leonard Swanson |
| 1933 |
Carl Keyser |
| 1932 |
Merrill MacNamee |
| 1931 |
Ralph Stock |
| 1930 |
Mark McElroy |
| 1929 |
Gordon Hulman |
| 1928 |
Virgil Walling |
| 1927 |
Frank Hovorka |
| 1926 |
Howard Norris |
| 1925 |
Harold Worley |
| 1924 |
Robert Hovorka |
| 1923 |
Frank Votaw |
| 1922 |
Herbert Stock |
| 1921 |
William Wiseman |
| 1920 |
David Cable |
| 1919 |
William Galberach |
| 1918 |
Leslie Trent |
| 1917 |
Lafayette Abbott |
| 1916 |
Lucian Axtell |
| 1915 |
Charles Kinder |
| 1914 |
Harry Gayer |
| 1913 |
Eric Tasman |
| 1912 |
Herald Bowlus |
| 1911 |
Howard Axtell |
| 1910 |
Chester Cable |
| 1909 |
Charles Siegchrist |
| 1908 |
George Southworth |
| 1907 |
George Clarke |
| 1906 |
George Clarke, Karl Rising |
| 1905 |
John Boggs |
| 1904 |
Edward Oliver |
| 1903 |
Fletcher Jackson, William Quinn |
| 1902 |
Kitto Carlisle |
| 1901 |
Edward Rodgers |
| 1900 |
Edward Rodgers |
